Casper & Runyon’s Shamrock's: The Nookie Challenge

March is a strange time of year in Minnesota.
Mostly, it's just plain soggy.

So on a day off in March, a proposition like this might be interesting: "Wanna come to Shamrocks's and watch some guys take the Nookie Challenge?"

Yes, I did. So I pulled on my boots, grabbed my bag, and headed to Casper & Runyon’s Shamrocks in St Paul.

Shamrocks is the sister restaurant to The Nook in St. Paul. The Nook is widely recognized for its Juicy Lucys, served two ways. Their Juicy Nookie burger is a burger stuffed with runny American cheese. Their Paul Moliter Burger is a burger stuffed with pepper cheese. They serve up hand-cut fries with their burgers, and they source their buns from P.J. Murphy’s on Randolph Ave. Shamrocks offers a similar menu to that of The Nook, and definitely carries the famous cheese-stuffed burgers.

I arrived at Shamrocks and ordered a Smithwick's. I was hopeful that my husband would split a Juicy Nookie with me. [He did. The Juicy Nookie was nicely charred, but slightly overcooked.]

Soon, the challengers arrived. They were seated at their reserved table, and presented with the challenge. The challenge was simple enough in theory: it required that one eat two Nookie Supreme burgers with fries.

photo swiped from Challenger John's Facebook page

One Nookie Supreme is two 1/3 cheeseburgers and special sauce on a bun with a heap of fries on the side. So the challenge was to eat 2 of these giant double cheeseburgers and two orders of fries. Yep, that's about a pound and a third of beef with all the fixings and fries.

4 men attempted the challenge. Two conquered it. All 4 of the men consumed both of their giant cheeseburgers, but only 2 of the 4 consumed all of their fries along with their burgers. According to the challengers, the fries became cold and unappetizing as the burgers were consumed.

All agreed it was a lot of food, and the two that completed the challenge were definitely feeling the pains of overeating.

The prize? A T-shirt that reads, "Have you had your Nookie Today? I did!" and, of course, bragging rights.


Eat giant burgers; get a shirt!
Casper & Runyon’s Shamrock's
995 Seventh St W
St Paul, MN 55102
(651) 228-9925

PS - I forgot to take my camera, but I managed to capture a couple of shots with my phone. Mea Culpa.

[where: Minnesota, Food, St Paul, Nookie Challenge, 55406]

3 comments:

Doni said...

My first Juicy Lucy experience ever was at The Nook (The Paul Molitor) and it turned me on to the whole craze in the TC's and has put me on a mission to find the best. I've had Juicy's twice at Shamrocks, and mine was overcooked last time too. Mmm... cheeeeese. :)

Reetsyburger said...

Doni - my first juicy Lucy was the Paul Moliter! My husband turned me on to the craze. He's been a Matt's junkie for years.

Cafe Cyan said...

My fav is the Paul Moliter - love it! It's great for takeout too because by the time I get home the burger is ready to eat :)